{% extends 'submissions/pool/base.html' %} {% load bootstrap %} {% load scipost_extras %} {% block breadcrumb_items %} {{ block.super }} Editorial Recommendation {% endblock %} {% block pagetitle %}: Editorial Recommendation{% endblock pagetitle %} {% block content %} {% if voting_form.errors %}

Warning: there was an error filling the voting form

{% for field in voting_form %} {% for error in field.errors %}
{{ error|escape }}
{% endfor %} {% endfor %} {% for error in voting_form.non_field_errors %}
{{ error|escape }}
{% endfor %}

Please go back to the form and try again!

{% endif %}

Editorial Recommendation to vote on

Concerning Submission:

{% include 'partials/submissions/submission_li.html' with submission=recommendation.submission %} View Reports and Submission details {% include 'partials/submissions/pool/submission_info_table.html' with submission=recommendation.submission %}
{% if recommendation.get_other_versions %}
{% for old_rec in recommendation.get_other_versions %} {% include 'partials/submissions/recommendation_fellow_content.html' with recommendation=old_rec %}

Fellows eligible to vote:

    {% for eligible in old_rec.eligible_to_vote.all|sort_by:'user__last_name' %}
  • {{ eligible.user.first_name }} {{ eligible.user.last_name }}
  • {% endfor %}

Voting results:

  • Agreed ({{ old_rec.voted_for.all.count }}): {% for agreed in old_rec.voted_for.all|sort_by:'user__last_name' %} {{ agreed.user.last_name }}{% if not forloop.last %},{% endif %} {% endfor %}
  • Disagreed ({{ old_rec.voted_against.all.count }}): {% for disagreed in old_rec.voted_against.all|sort_by:'user__last_name' %} {{ disagreed.user.last_name }}{% if not forloop.last %},{% endif %} {% endfor %}
  • Abstained ({{ old_rec.voted_abstain.all.count }}): {% for abstained in old_rec.voted_abstain.all|sort_by:'user__last_name' %} {{ abstained.user.last_name }}{% if not forloop.last %},{% endif %} {% endfor %}
{% if old_rec.submission.tierings.all|length > 0 %}

Tierings specified by voting Fellows

    {% for tiering in old_rec.submission.tierings.all %}
  • {{ tiering.fellow }}: for Journal {{ tiering.for_journal }}: {{ tiering.get_tier_display }}
  • {% endfor %}
{% endif %} {% if old_rec.alternativerecommendation_set.all|length > 0 %}

Alternative recommendations offered during voting by Fellows who disagreed:

    {% for altrec in old_rec.alternativerecommendation_set.all %}
  • {{ altrec.fellow }}: for Journal {{ altrec.for_journal }}: {{ altrec.get_recommendation_display }}
  • {% endfor %}
{% endif %}

Remarks:

    {% for rem in old_rec.remarks.all %}
  • {% include 'partials/submissions/remark_small.html' with remark=rem %}
  • {% empty %}
  • No remarks
  • {% endfor %}
{% endfor %}
{% endif %}

Editorial Recommendation to vote on

{% include 'partials/submissions/recommendation_fellow_content.html' with recommendation=recommendation %}

Fellows eligible to vote:

Voting results up to now:

{% if recommendation.submission.tierings.all|length > 0 %}

Tierings for this Submission, as indicated by voting Fellows who agreed with publication

{% for tiering in recommendation.submission.tierings.all %} {% endfor %}
Fellow For Journal Tier
{{ tiering.fellow }} {{ tiering.for_journal }} {{ tiering.get_tier_display }}
{% endif %} {% if recommendation.alternativerecommendation_set.all|length > 0 %}

Alternative recommendations offered during voting by Fellows who disagreed:

{% for altrec in recommendation.alternativerecommendation_set.all %} {% endfor %}
Fellow For Journal Alternative Recommendation
{{ altrec.fellow }} {{ altrec.for_journal }} {{ altrec.get_recommendation_display }}
{% endif %}

Remarks:

{% if perms.scipost.can_fix_College_decision %} {% endif %}
{% if voting_form %}

Your position on this recommendation

{% if previous_vote %}

You had previously voted {{ previous_vote }}; you can use the form below to change your vote and/or add a remark:

{% endif %}

{% if recommendation.recommendation == 1 %} If you agree with a recommendation to publish, you can provide your ballpark quality tiering below
(this is not compulsory, but most welcome) {% endif %}

If you vote disagree, please provide an alternative recommendation below

{% csrf_token %} {{ voting_form|bootstrap }}
{% endif %} {% endblock %} {% block footer_script %} {% endblock %}