SciPost Commentary Page (non-SciPost publications)
{{ commentary.header_as_table|safe }}
Abstract:
{{ commentary.pub_abstract }}
Ratings:
- clarity: {{ commentary.clarity_rating }}% ({{ commentary.nr_clarity_ratings }})
- validity: {{ commentary.validity_rating }}% ({{ commentary.nr_validity_ratings }})
- rigour: {{ commentary.rigour_rating }}% ({{ commentary.nr_rigour_ratings }})
- originality: {{ commentary.originality_rating }}% ({{ commentary.nr_originality_ratings }})
- significance: {{ commentary.significance_rating }}% ({{ commentary.nr_significance_ratings }})
{% if user.is_authenticated and user.contributor.rank > 0 %}
{% endif %}
{% if reports %}
Category:
{% if comment.is_rem %}- remark
{% endif %}
{% if comment.is_que %}- question
{% endif %}
{% if comment.is_ans %}- answer to question
{% endif %}
{% if comment.is_obj %}- objection
{% endif %}
{% if comment.is_rep %}- reply to objection
{% endif %}
{% if comment.is_val %}- validation or rederivation
{% endif %}
{% if comment.is_lit %}- pointer to related literature
{% endif %}
{% if comment.is_sug %}- suggestion for further work
{% endif %}
Ratings:
Comment text:
Author reply ({{ reply.date_submitted }}):
Ratings:
{{ reply.reply_text|linebreaks }}
Reply to this comment (Author)
Reply to this comment (Contributor)