{% extends 'scipost/base.html' %} {% block pagetitle %}: Commentary detail{% endblock pagetitle %} {% block headsup %} {% endblock headsup %} {% block bodysup %} {% if user.is_authenticated %}

SciPost Commentary Page   (for non-SciPost publications)



Original publication:

Title: {{ commentary.pub_title }}
Author(s): {{ commentary.author_list }}
arXiv link: {{ commentary.arxiv_link }}
DOI Link: {{ commentary.pub_DOI_link }}
Date published: {{ commentary.pub_date }}

Abstract:

{{ commentary.pub_abstract }}

Ratings:


{% if user.is_authenticated and user.contributor.rank > 0 %}
{% csrf_token %}
{% endif %}
{% if reports %}

Reports on this publication


{% endif %} {% if comments %}

Comments on this publication

{% for comment in comments %}
{{ comment.print_identifier|safe }}

Category:

    {% if comment.is_rem %}
  • remark
  • {% endif %} {% if comment.is_que %}
  • question
  • {% endif %} {% if comment.is_ans %}
  • answer to question
  • {% endif %} {% if comment.is_obj %}
  • objection
  • {% endif %} {% if comment.is_rep %}
  • reply to objection
  • {% endif %} {% if comment.is_val %}
  • validation or rederivation
  • {% endif %} {% if comment.is_lit %}
  • pointer to related literature
  • {% endif %} {% if comment.is_sug %}
  • suggestion for further work
  • {% endif %}

Ratings:

  • Relevance: {{ comment.relevance_rating }}% ({{ comment.nr_relevance_ratings }})
  • Importance: {{ comment.importance_rating }}% ({{ comment.nr_importance_ratings }})
  • Clarity: {{ comment.clarity_rating }}% ({{ comment.nr_clarity_ratings }})
  • Validity: {{ comment.validity_rating }}% ({{ comment.nr_validity_ratings }})
  • Rigour: {{ comment.rigour_rating }}% ({{ comment.nr_rigour_ratings }})

Comment text:

{{ comment.comment_text|linebreaks }}

{% if user.is_authenticated and user.contributor.rank > 0 %}
{% csrf_token %}
    {{ comment_rating_form.as_ul }}
{% endif %}
{% for reply in author_replies %} {% if reply.in_reply_to_comment.id = comment.id %}

Author reply ({{ reply.date_submitted }}):

Ratings:

  • relevance: {{ reply.relevance_rating }}% ({{ reply.nr_relevance_ratings }})
  • importance: {{ reply.importance_rating }}% ({{ reply.nr_importance_ratings }})
  • clarity: {{ reply.clarity_rating }}% ({{ reply.nr_clarity_ratings }})
  • validity: {{ reply.validity_rating }}% ({{ reply.nr_validity_ratings }})
  • rigour: {{ reply.rigour_rating }}% ({{ reply.nr_rigour_ratings }})

{{ reply.reply_text|linebreaks }}

{% if user.is_authenticated and user.contributor.rank > 0 %}
{% csrf_token %}
    {{ authorreply_rating_form.as_ul }}
{% endif %} {% endif %} {% endfor %} {% if user.is_authenticated and user.contributor.rank > 0 %}

{% endif %} {% endfor %}
{% endif %} {% if user.is_authenticated and commentary.open_for_commenting and user.contributor.rank > 0 %}

Contribute a Comment

Specify which category your comment belongs to (you can choose more than one).

In your comment, you can use LaTeX \$...\$ for in-text equations or \ [ ... \ ] for on-line equations.

{% csrf_token %}
  • Specify categorization:

  • {{ form.is_rem }} remark
  • {{ form.is_que }} question
  • {{ form.is_ans }} answer to question
  • {{ form.is_obj }} objection
  • {{ form.is_rep }} reply to objection
  • {{ form.is_val }} validation or rederivation
  • {{ form.is_lit }} pointer to related literature
  • {{ form.is_sug }} suggestion for further work

Write your comment here:

{{ form.comment_text }}

Publish anonymously {{ form.anonymous }}

Be professional. Only serious and meaningful comments will be vetted through. By clicking on Submit, the commenter certifies that all sources used are duly referenced and cited. Failure to do so will lead to exclusion from the portal.

{% endif %} {% endif %} {% endblock bodysup %}