Your {% if form.instance.is_followup_report %}followup {% endif %}report:
A preview of text areas will appear below as you type (you can use $\LaTeX$ \$...\$ for in-text equations or \ [ ... \ ] for on-line equations).
Before you get started, please make sure you are familiar with our referee guidelines , editorial procedure and referee code of conduct .
This manuscript was submitted to {{ submission.submitted_to }} . Please make sure that you refer to this journal's acceptance criteria in your evaluation.
If you feel the article would be more appropriately published in one of our other {{ submission.adac_field }} Journals , please
select Accept in alternative Journal in the Recommendation field
in the Report field, specify the alternative Journal in which you would recommend acceptance
example 1 : This submission transcends the criteria of [Journal 1] and meets those of [Journal A], it should be published in the latter
example 2 : This submission does not meet the criteria of [Journal A], but does meet those of [Journal 1], where it could be published.
Required fields
text field for report
recommendation (publish? revise? reject?)
optional remarks for the editors only
anonymity specifier
Optional fields
qualification specifier
text fields for strengths, weaknesses, report, requested changes
and specifiers for validity, significance, originality, clarity, formatting and grammar
Show required fields only
Show all fields
{% if form.instance.is_followup_report %}
Because you have already submitted a Report for this Submission series, not all fields are required.
{% endif %}