{% extends 'submissions/base.html' %} {% block breadcrumb_items %} {{ block.super }} Submit a report {% endblock %} {% load bootstrap %} {% load static %} {% block pagetitle %}: submit report{% endblock pagetitle %} {% block content %} {% if user.is_authenticated %}

Submit a Report on a SciPost Submission

Submission

{% include 'submissions/_submission_summary.html' with submission=submission show_abstract=1 %}

Your {% if form.instance.is_followup_report %}followup {% endif %}report:

A preview of text areas will appear below as you type (you can use $\LaTeX$ \$...\$ for in-text equations or \ [ ... \ ] for on-line equations).

Before you get started, please make sure you are familiar with our referee guidelines, editorial procedure and referee code of conduct.

Important!

  • This manuscript was submitted to {{ submission.submitted_to }}. Please make sure that you refer to this journal's acceptance criteria in your evaluation.
  • If you feel the article would be more appropriately published in one of our other {{ submission.adac_field }} Journals, please
    • select Accept in alternative Journal in the Recommendation field
    • in the Report field, specify the alternative Journal in which you would recommend acceptance
      • example 1: This submission transcends the criteria of [Journal 1] and meets those of [Journal A], it should be published in the latter
      • example 2: This submission does not meet the criteria of [Journal A], but does meet those of [Journal 1], where it could be published.
Required fields
  • text field for report
  • recommendation (publish? revise? reject?)
  • optional remarks for the editors only
  • anonymity specifier
Optional fields
  • qualification specifier
  • text fields for strengths, weaknesses, report, requested changes
  • and specifiers for validity, significance, originality, clarity, formatting and grammar
{% if form.instance.is_followup_report %}

Because you have already submitted a Report for this Submission series, not all fields are required.

{% endif %}
{% if form.report_type == 'report_post_edrec' %}
The Editorial Recommendation for this Submission has already been formulated. Therefore, your report will be labelled as .
{% endif %}

{% csrf_token %} {{ form|bootstrap:'12,12' }}

Any fields with an asterisk (*) are required.

{% if form.report_type == 'report_post_edrec' %}
The Editorial Recommendation for this Submission has already been formulated. Therefore, your report will be labelled as .
{% endif %}
By clicking on Submit, you state that you abide by the referee code of conduct.

{% include 'submissions/_report_preview.html' %}
{% endif %} {% endblock %} {% block footer_script %} {% endblock %}