{% load staticfiles %} {% load mathjax %} {% mathjax_scripts %} {% include 'scipost/header.html' %} {% include 'scipost/navbar.html' %}

SciPost Commentary Page   (for non-SciPost publications)

Original publication:

  • Ratings:
  • clarity: {{ commentary.clarity_rating }}% ({{ commentary.nr_clarity_ratings }})
  • validity: {{ commentary.validity_rating }}% ({{ commentary.nr_validity_ratings }})
  • rigour: {{ commentary.rigour_rating }}% ({{ commentary.nr_rigour_ratings }})
  • originality: {{ commentary.originality_rating }}% ({{ commentary.nr_originality_ratings }})
  • significance: {{ commentary.significance_rating }}% ({{ commentary.nr_significance_ratings }})

Title: {{ commentary.pub_title }}
Author(s): {{ commentary.author_list }}
arXiv link: {{ commentary.arxiv_link }}
DOI Link: {{ commentary.pub_DOI_link }}
Date published: {{ commentary.pub_date }}

Abstract:

{{ commentary.pub_abstract }}

{% if user.is_authenticated %}
{% csrf_token %}
{% endif %}
{% if reports %}

Reports on this publication


{% endif %} {% if comments %}

Comments on this publication


{% for comment in comments %}

{{ comment.id }}   {% if comment.in_reply_to %} (in reply to {{ comment.in_reply_to.id }}) {% endif %}

Date: {{ comment.date_submitted }}

  • Ratings:
  • relevance: {{ comment.relevance_rating }}% ({{ comment.nr_relevance_ratings }})
  • importance: {{ comment.importance_rating }}% ({{ comment.nr_importance_ratings }})
  • clarity: {{ comment.clarity_rating }}% ({{ comment.nr_clarity_ratings }})
  • validity: {{ comment.validity_rating }}% ({{ comment.nr_validity_ratings }})
  • rigour: {{ comment.rigour_rating }}% ({{ comment.nr_rigour_ratings }})

{{ comment.comment_text }}

{% if user.is_authenticated %}
{% csrf_token %}
  • Rate this comment:
  • {{ comment_rating_form.as_ul }}
{% endif %} {% for reply in author_replies %} {% if reply.in_reply_to_comment.id = comment.id %}

Author reply ({{ reply.date_submitted }}):

{{ reply.reply_text }}

{% endif %} {% endfor %}

{% endfor %}
{% endif %} {% if user.is_authenticated and commentary.open_for_commenting %}

Contribute a Comment

{% csrf_token %} {{ form }}
{% endif %} {% include 'scipost/footer.html' %}